Representations of Women Writers in Film, Fiction, Memoirs
- At June 01, 2013
- By Jeannine Gailey
- In Blog
4
Okay, I thought I would do a post on how marriage was like The Hunger Games. But I’ll save that for another day, because yesterday there was a sneaky snake attack by my little lake full of ducklings – a four-and-a-half foot black snake charged me out of nowhere, which has never happend to me before – and I was on a wet grassy bank, so I jumped, fell, sprained my ankle, pulled my knee and bruised my spine. (Ouch – sleeping last night wasn’t pleasant! But thank goodness I had an appointment with my physical therapist, who was able to check my injuries and tape up my knee and ankle. Anyway, this all leads to the fact that I’ve been reading and listening to books non-stop.
So, we watched “The Squid and The Whale” – which critics just loved, but I just felt “meh” about – I kind of hated the representation of the tarty, successful writer/mother character and I thought the kids were awfully whiny – I mean, those writers/parents weren’t winning any parenting contests, but then, I think I know a lot of x-er childhoods that were a lot more traumatic (including my own, almost all of my friends and most of those closest to me.) Then I was reading “Z – a Novel of Zelda Fitzgerald” – I just saw the new Gatsby movie, which I loved, but I conflated – I think incorrectly – Zelda and Daisy from Gatsby, so I had Fitzgeralds on the brain – and doing some research on her life, discovered she died, rather pathetically, in a sanatorium fire at the age of 48 with eight other women. And you know I’ve been reading Flannery’s letters, yes, funny and tough, but who died at 39 of complications from lupus – and I’m reading two books on Sylvia Plath, Pain, parties, work : Sylvia Plath in New York, summer 1953 and Mad Girl’s Love Song, which are both about Sylvia life as a young woman. And we all knew what happened to her. Sigh.
I just wish there were some representations of happy, balanced women writers somewhere – in fiction, film, memoir….I was thinking that maybe the closest I come to healthy role models are Margaret Atwood and AS Byatt – both well known for their grumpiness but also fairly old and not that tragic! Can you think of some positive fictional or memoir representations of women writers? How about films? I think every film I’ve ever seen in which a woman writer appeared, the writer was a. tragic/pathetic b. deeply neurotic or c. a love interest, not a main character. How am I supposed to do this woman-writer thing with everyone dying young or going crazy? Help me out! I’m stuck inside and need something cheerful to watch/read to inspire me!
Karen
Thanks for the post! I try to find clips from movies about writers to show the “writing life” but don’t have any clips about women writers (although there are interesting depictions of women journalists in movies….)
I think there’s a movie about Beatrix Potter out there (I haven’t seen it) — probably not the writer you are looking for, but it may be interesting (I loved Beatrix Potter when I was a kid!)
Felicity
I have some suggestions!
First of all, Lucy M. Boston, children’s writer, British. My mom has read her two memoirs which are collected as Memories, and likes them very much. She was also a painter, a gardener, and a fascinating person, reportedly cheerful to the very end if her long life.
Secondly, Rumer Godden, who wrote adult & children’s lit. She has two memoirs which my mom has liked, and there’s a biography by Anne Chisholm that neither of us has read.
How about P.D. James, whose mysteries are more accepted as “literary” than anyone I can think of? There was a recent memoir, Time to Be in Earnest, which I’ve heard was very good.
I don’t know that there’s any bio of Josephine Tey, who was very private, but then she did only make it to 56 (cancer.) I love her books.
Too many Brits? How about Eudora Welty? Lived to a ripe old age, and I hear she was a happy, sociable person.
Toni Morrison? She seems busy as a bee, but I have never heard that her personal life is tragic at all.
Jennifer Drake Thornton
If you accept Jo March as a very lightly fictionalized version of Louisa May Alcott, she comes off pretty well in film. But that is reaching quite a ways back.
Kristin Berkey-Abbott
I’ve got a long list of women writers who have made it deep into adulthood with great books and good relationships. I’ll abbreviate, but continue thinking about this list, if you want more examples.
Margaret Drabble, Byatt’s sister, has had a very calm life, aside from spats with her sister.
On this side of the pond: Gail Godwin, Marge Piercy, . . . I’m seeing a trend. I think that women writers who were part of the feminist movement and/or started writing after the feminist movement have less of the drama of the Sylvia Plaths and the Zelda Fitzgeralds.
I also think that medical and mental health advances of recent decades give more of us a shot at living longer, more productive lives. The odds were really stacked against women of the 19th and early 20th centuries. Penicillin and reliable birth control have really been more precious gifts than many of us realize.